You've completed your SR-22 requirement in Illinois, but your AAIP assignment might still be affecting your rates. Here's how AAIP works, when you exit, and what to expect from carriers once you're out.
What is the Illinois Auto Assigned Risk Plan (AAIP)?
The Illinois Auto Assigned Risk Plan assigns high-risk drivers who cannot find voluntary coverage to carriers operating in the state. Carriers are required to accept a proportional share of assigned risk drivers based on their market share in Illinois. You enter AAIP when standard and non-standard carriers decline you — typically after a DUI, multiple violations, or SR-22 filing requirement.
AAIP coverage costs 25–60% more than voluntary non-standard policies because carriers price assigned risk as guaranteed-issue business. The Secretary of State's office does not assign you to AAIP — carriers do, by declining your application. If every carrier you contact refuses voluntary coverage, your insurance agent or the Illinois Department of Insurance can route your application into the AAIP system.
Once assigned, you remain in AAIP until a carrier offers you voluntary coverage or you request reconsideration after your risk profile improves. Most post-SR22 drivers qualify for voluntary non-standard coverage within 6–12 months after their filing ends, but they stay in AAIP because they don't actively shop or request reassignment.
How SR-22 Filing Connects to AAIP Assignment
Illinois requires SR-22 filing for 3 years after specific violations, including DUI, driving on a suspended license, multiple at-fault accidents, and uninsured driving convictions. The SR-22 is not insurance — it's a certificate your carrier files with the Illinois Secretary of State proving you carry at least the state minimum liability coverage: 25/50/20.
When you need SR-22 and no voluntary carrier will write your policy, you enter AAIP. Your assigned carrier files the SR-22 on your behalf. The filing period and the AAIP assignment are separate timelines. Your 3-year SR-22 requirement ends on the date the Secretary of State specifies, but your AAIP assignment continues until you qualify for voluntary coverage and actively request reconsideration.
Carriers writing voluntary non-standard auto in Illinois — Progressive, National General, and Bristol West among them — evaluate post-SR22 drivers based on time since violation, claims history, and whether the SR-22 filing is still active. Once your filing ends and 6–12 months pass without new violations, most carriers reconsider. You must request quotes. AAIP does not automatically release you to the voluntary market.
Find out exactly how long SR-22 is required in your state
When You Exit AAIP After Your SR-22 Ends
You become eligible to exit AAIP once your SR-22 filing period ends and you demonstrate 6–12 months of continuous coverage without lapses or new violations. Eligibility does not trigger automatic exit. You must shop for voluntary coverage and receive an acceptance offer from a non-standard carrier.
Most post-SR22 drivers in Illinois see voluntary non-standard rates 30–50% lower than AAIP pricing within the first year after filing ends. Rates continue to drop as time since violation increases. At the 2-year post-SR22 mark, drivers with no new violations typically qualify for standard non-standard rates comparable to drivers with one at-fault accident. At 3 years post-filing, some drivers return to preferred or standard tiers depending on overall record.
The rate recovery curve depends on violation type. DUI drivers face longer recovery timelines than drivers assigned for multiple speeding tickets or uninsured driving. Carriers evaluate the original violation that triggered SR-22, not just the fact that filing occurred. A DUI with SR-22 takes 3–5 years to reach standard pricing. An uninsured motorist violation with SR-22 typically clears in 2–3 years.
Which Illinois Carriers Write Post-SR22 Drivers
Progressive, National General, Bristol West, Dairyland, and The General actively write voluntary non-standard auto for post-SR22 drivers in Illinois. Progressive offers the broadest appetite — they quote most drivers 6 months after SR-22 ends if no new violations occurred. National General and Bristol West typically require 12 months post-filing before quoting voluntary coverage.
Dairyland specializes in high-risk drivers transitioning out of SR-22 and AAIP. They price competitively for drivers 6–18 months post-filing. The General writes drivers with recent SR-22 completion but prices higher than Dairyland or Progressive for similar profiles. Acceptance and rate vary by individual underwriting — time since violation, claims history, and coverage lapse record all affect the quote.
State Farm, Allstate, and Country Financial — the dominant standard carriers in Illinois — rarely write drivers within 3 years of SR-22 completion. GEICO writes selectively for post-SR22 drivers 2+ years out with clean records since filing ended. Shopping across non-standard carriers during your first 6 months post-SR22 produces the widest rate spread and highest likelihood of exiting AAIP.
What Post-SR22 Drivers Pay in Illinois
AAIP pricing for post-SR22 drivers in Illinois runs $180–$280/mo for state minimum liability coverage. Voluntary non-standard carriers quote $120–$190/mo for the same coverage once you exit AAIP, depending on time since violation and carrier. Full coverage with comprehensive and collision adds $60–$110/mo to either rate.
Drivers 12 months post-SR22 with no new violations typically see quotes in the $110–$160/mo range for liability-only policies from Progressive, Dairyland, and Bristol West. At 24 months post-filing, rates drop to $95–$140/mo. At 36 months, drivers with clean records since SR-22 ended reach $80–$120/mo, approaching standard non-standard pricing.
Violation type affects rate trajectory. DUI drivers remain in higher tiers longer — expect $140–$200/mo even 18 months post-SR22. Uninsured motorist violations and suspended license filings clear faster, with rates approaching $90–$130/mo at the 18-month mark. Every carrier prices post-SR22 history differently. Comparing quotes across 3–5 non-standard carriers every 6 months during your recovery period captures the steepest rate drops.
How to Trigger AAIP Exit and Get Voluntary Coverage
Contact a non-standard auto insurance agent or use an online comparison tool that includes Progressive, National General, Dairyland, Bristol West, and The General. Request quotes 6 months after your SR-22 filing ends. Provide your SR-22 end date, original violation type, and proof of continuous coverage since filing.
If carriers decline at 6 months, request quotes again at 12 months. Rate acceptance and pricing improve materially between month 6 and month 12 post-filing. If you receive a voluntary offer, accept it immediately. Your AAIP assignment ends the day your voluntary policy begins. Notify your current AAIP carrier of cancellation only after your new voluntary policy is active to avoid coverage gaps.
If you remain in AAIP beyond 12 months post-SR22 without shopping, you are overpaying. Assigned risk pricing does not decrease with time. Voluntary non-standard pricing does. The difference between staying in AAIP for 24 months versus exiting at 6 months costs most drivers $1,200–$2,400 in unnecessary premium.
